What if my pil pil sauce won't emulsify?
Most likely the oil was too hot during the swirling stage. The gelatin denatures above about 70°C and loses its emulsifying power. Let the oil cool to warm — press the outside of the pan; it should feel comfortably warm, not hot — then try swirling again with a mesh strainer. If the sauce is completely broken (looks like separated, greasy oil), warm it very gently over the lowest possible heat while adding a tablespoon of warm water and swirling continuously. Sometimes it recovers. If not, serve the cod with the garlic oil poured over it; the flavour will still be excellent, just without the emulsion.


